Home > Surveillance > Monitoring CCTV for Money

Monitoring CCTV for Money

By: Thomas Muller - Updated: 23 Aug 2012 | comments*Discuss
 
Cctv Monitoring Surveillance Cash

With its poor record in fighting crime CCTV is struggling to justify its huge cost and attack on civil liberties, but will offering members of the public money to spot video wrong-doing help improve its effectiveness?

Why is Surveillance Ineffective?

The UK’s vast network of over 4 million CCTV cameras has been heavily criticised for failing to warrant its huge drain on public expense. A recent report into London’s surveillance system claims that during the previous year only one crime had been solved for every 1,000 of the capitol’s CCTV cameras.

It is also argued that beyond the billions of pounds spent on the technology, CCTV comes at the expense of civil liberties but with little payback in the form of improved security.

Why is CCTV not proving to be as effective as promised? Is video surveillance ultimately limited in its effectiveness or is it just not being used to its full potential?

Monitoring CCTV for Cash Rewards

Some believe that the network is failing because the footage is not being adequately monitored in real time but only referred back to, once a serious crime has been committed. It is an attitude that has helped eradicate the fear of CCTV and the technology’s power as a deterrent.

It also inspired a scheme launched in 2010 by a private company in which members of the public assume the role of the CCTV monitoring staff. Scanning commercial CCTV footage streamed online, they report any suspicious activity such as shoplifting in exchange for cash rewards.

Having paid an annual subscription fee, participants are given four simultaneous screens to scan taken from cameras installed in random shops and other businesses that have chosen to take part in the programme. If the viewer spots anything untoward they are able to press an 'alert' button that sends an instant text message with accompanying image to a nominated shop assistant or manager. The business can then decide whether to confront any suspected wrongdoer or call security.

If any misdemeanours are spotted, subscribers are eligible for a share in a reward pot of up to £1,000.

Pros and Cons

On its launch the scheme was promoted as helping to reduce crime and prevent other anti-social behaviour by acting both as an effective security monitor and deterrent.

At a time of newly announced budget cuts and with the Conservative Party’s ‘Big Society’ initiative, which encouraged citizens to get more involved in running their local services, still fresh in the mind, the scheme was even hailed as one way people could help out local communities.

Conversely, some argued that, rather than contribute to society, people that watch the world through a monitor and report on the people they see on the screen are less likely to be able to play an active part in the community.

The scheme has also drawn fierce criticism from civil rights campaigners, who described it as “distasteful”, “Big Brother-style snooping”, and likened it to a game in that it encourages private citizens to spy on each other for cash prizes.

Texas Border Watch

Other critics simply condemned it as being doomed to fail, citing an inauspicious precedent in the USA.

Launched in 2008, the ‘Texas Virtual Border Watch Program’ allowed anyone in the world to log on via the Internet and watch a live feed from the Texas-Mexico border to report any suspicious activity, such as smuggling. During its first year of action, the scheme produced information leading to 12 arrests and extensive reports on the movements of local wildlife – scant yield for $2 million of investment. Needless to say the programme soon ran short of money...and its backers, out of patience.

Longtime Value?The failure of the US scheme could be seen to support the idea that the relative ineffectiveness of the UK’s CCTV network is not due to any inadequate monitoring but because that video surveillance itself is ineffective as a means of preventing and solving crime.

But this may seem too rash a condemnation. Police have said that CCTV has proven ineffective because all the investment has been on the technology and not on how the images can be used most effectively, such as in building a national CCTV image database.

Whether encouraging CCTV viewers to spot crimes with the aid of cash incentives will also improve its effectiveness remains to be seen.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Topics
Latest Comments
  • Iona
    Re: How to Join MI6
    I'm 16, but i wanna train to become a spy when i'm 18. I'm going to college in september and after i leave college, i wanna start to train and…
    3 July 2018
  • DIYSpy
    Re: How to Join MI6
    Mary - Your Question:Hi I am 12 and from the UK. I grew up watching the TV show Mi high' (a children's television programme on the BBC about children
    18 June 2018
  • Mary
    Re: How to Join MI6
    Hi I am 12 and from the UK. I grew up watching the TV show Mi high' (a children's television programme on the BBC about children in the Mi…
    16 June 2018
  • K.c
    Re: How to Join MI6
    I am 14 and have no experience. I train nearly everyday ,i take it very seriously. I have been told of my cousin that I should go and reach my goal…
    11 June 2018
  • Sam
    Re: How to Join MI6
    I am 13 and have had a little bit of experience and I want to aim for a better job which is the ml6. I have got told by the person I work for that…
    20 May 2018
  • rex
    Re: How to Join MI6
    I have abilities. Its the future, new frontier, space race , scramble for Africa.I hope this information is in safe hands.
    14 May 2018
  • Salem
    Re: How to Join MI6
    Hi sir/madam How are you hope everything is going well with you. I have a great interest to work for MI6 . I'm an Afghan citizen. Due to bad life…
    17 March 2018
  • deji
    Re: How to Join MI6
    I'm only 12 but I know I will be a good recruit because I am agile and intelligent for my age and I'm young and be able to fit in to small spaces…
    12 March 2018
  • Swento
    Re: How to Join MI6
    Hi l am 14 years old boy and l am a Ugandan l have been dreaming of becoming a MI6 agent l am a faster learner with some learning skills .l enjoy…
    6 March 2018
  • DIYSpy
    Re: How to Join MI6
    Billy Wilson - Your Question:Hi, I am a 12 year old boy from the U.K. I have seen many movies and played many games that are to do with all the spy…
    6 March 2018